by Cecily Winter

My gory serial killer story THE NAME-US GAME COUNTERPOINT is available in a paperback anthology titled POTTER’S FIELD 7, edited by Tyree Campbell at . Several stories–especially those by Mike Morgan, Tyree Campbell, and James Dorr–and Colleen Anderson’s poetry blew my socks off.
A slightly more elegant version of NAME-US is available in MADAME GRAY’S VAULT OF GORE, edited by Gerri R. Gray. I have yet to read the stories of my fellow contributors but expect to be thoroughly entertained. MADAME GRAY’S VAULT OF GORE at Amazon.
THE NAME-US GAME COUNTERPOINT
By Cecily Winter
He woke at his desk fully dressed and shook his head to dislodge the fug from his brain. His laptop screen glowed and he tapped it. Weirdly, it blossomed into the police sketch of Star Silver. Her real name was Kim, his first, and he still recalled her silken hair threaded through his fingers. Too bad she broke so soon.
He must’ve been tripping all night because he didn’t recall leaving the house and trolling for the Kim under his motel-standard duvet. Over the years, he’d spent a fortune on bedclothes. DNA was a bitch, and here he was playing the odds when money was short.
A wisp of smoke visible through a gap in the drapes told him he’d burned her clothes. He got up and twitched the drapes closed. He didn’t want peeping Toms or nosy Parkers calling the cops. On second thoughts, the smoke could have been from the beach blanket still smoldering after yesterday’s rain. If it didn’t ash up soon, he’d douse it with gas.
It was barely dawn, and his grandma’s stone farmhouse would be chilly until the sun got high. He occupied just three rooms: his easy-clean bedroom-cum-living room, spartan in the extreme; the bathroom with lime-green fixtures from the 1940s; and the kitchen about which the less said the better. He’d long ago stopped climbing to the second floor. The roof leaked, and it was a mess, but his dad’s mess and he was long gone. Found face-down and fox-nibbled in the old cornfield. Verdict—heart attack. Maybe the Devil said “boo.”
He entered the doorless bathroom. Like he figured: he’d been way out of it. Had he been roofied? He selected a packaged toothbrush from the vanity drawer, set it beside the sink, then selected one of several plain gray sweatsuits from the closet and folded the pieces on the toilet seat as per usual.
The new Kim tiptoed toward him, stark-naked and hugging her arms tight about her breasts.
She asked, “Where’d you put my clothes?”
“Take a shower. You can wear the sweats.”
She didn’t argue. Baby in the sandbox. He liked them to argue. It raised the temperature.
No lock on the bathroom door, so steam billowed to his laptop where he sat spot-lit by a beam of sunrise making headway through a chip in the blacked-out transom. While he waited, he searched his mind for the place he’d picked up the Kim. He like a written record, not his own—the essential details were engraved in his memory—but on the website of the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System. Since he’d first logged on to NamUs a while back, a bunch of girly Jane Does had been identified and labeled with their real names.
He didn’t care for girlie names—Barbie, Juliet, Tiffany. After his mother took off—she was a Kim if he remembered rightly—when he’d been five, he’d methodically stabbed and dismembered all her Barbie collectibles then buried their plastic bits in a cornfield grave. Not allowed to strike matches, he dumped their clothes in the kitchen trash. Decades later, the last time he’d been upstairs, his mother’s clothes still hung laundered and ironed in her bedroom closet.
He always christened his girls Kim, though not all were blondes or shapely. Why not gorge on the sample pack?
In his memory, he recorded only the dates and cities where he picked them up: Kim/May 14, 2021/Wildwood; Kim/October 3, 2019/Jenkintown; Kim/February 7, 2018/Cape May. He’d been almost 17 with the first in Brooklyn. Her arterial blood messed up his truck—Dad was pissed but he’d avoided major spillage ever since.
He rarely ventured so far these days. Too much stress driving long-distance with hookers or Goodtime girlies doped, dying, or dead. When the site excised people, it meant they’d been identified, found, and returned in body bags to their next of kin or a potter’s field. He never followed the news to see where the investigations had stalled but caught a TV blurb last week on the Wildwood hiker. He’d been sunbathing, wind-bathing more like, and preferred to take his time for burial, but a scare from a cruiser siren forced him to leave that Kim exposed to the crabs and gulls between a couple of dunes. He checked her out on the website. Brand new file captioned as a Jane Doe with details of her coloring and approximate age. Only 15, though she’d demanded cash up front.
Cops never once showed up at his door. Dad had taught him the techniques of stealth hunting—squirrel, possum, and crows mainly, but they worked for girlies too and no noisy bang.
He flinched when new Kim’s hair brushed the back of his neck as she leaned over his shoulder and her minty breath almost covered the stink of her sweat. Wow. How long would it take to scrub it all off? She must’ve been on the road a long while. She wore his bathrobe, which swamped her. Why didn’t she follow instructions and put on the sweats he left out?
He glanced at the family photo at the rear of the desk—the last one taken in his family. His Barbie-collecting mother with her face scratched out, Dad with beefy eye pouches, and him aged five when he was cute as a Disney grasshopper.
“This your hobby,” she asked, “helping the cops and families of those missing people?”
Her voice was rich and melodic and somehow familiar like she’d been on the radio or was a chorus girl like Star Silver Kim, there to make his day with her special brand of whoopie.
“Keeps me spinning on the wheel of fortune,” he said, catching back a snigger. “I’m drawing a blank on how we hooked up. Where was that?”
She punted the question. “You ever crack a case?”
“You doped me last night?”
“Maybe.”
“You could have had me free and clear if you’d asked.”
She didn’t smile, and he eased closed the laptop. “Cracking a case isn’t the point.”
“How’s that?”
He had no answer she wanted to hear. “You need joe? I got instant.”
“Water’s good. I’m parched.”
“Sure.”
He got up easily, limber as a cougar, and swept the cottage for escape routes. Windows nailed shut, ratty drapes still drawn, and the front and back doors key-locked and bolted high. She could jump out a second-floor window but the rotted floorboards wouldn’t hold her weight.
In the steamy bathroom, a corona of soil rimmed the bathtub drain. The faucet trickled water into a Dixie cup. Faucet was clogged. It busted him up sometimes, how he was forced to live: a sagging roof, fast food on the run, a garbage pile out back the size of Montana. Maybe he’d find a new hunting lodge.
The farm had gone under long before he dropped out of high school. He didn’t know how his dad made money but they lived off the grid, not even a phone, and aside from that he’d never wanted for anything. Got a second-hand truck for his 16th birthday. No cake and candles though.
It wouldn’t be hard to abandon it. The house, an igloo in winter, a fly-blown furnace in summer, and there was talk of an eminent domain taking for a new highway. He couldn’t stick around if the bulldozers got busy. The cornfield was a potter’s field of tortured Barbies and life-surrendered Kims.
At his desk, Kim leaned on her elbows, her fists punched into her cheeks. She was engrossed in the screen and didn’t flinch when he crept up from behind in noiseless shoes.
“Good with computers, are you?” he asked, crowding her with his body.
“Never used one before, but these faces popped up.”
He frowned at the NamUs array on screen. Hadn’t he shut it down? Photos or sketches of all his Kims were arranged in a grid like they were about to identify him. It was spooky.
“Who are they?” she asked as he handed her the paper cup.
“Missing women. There are thousands.”
She drank the water in one gulp like the night’s workout sucked her dry. He couldn’t recall a thing about it, and her skin showed no wear and tear. He must have blacked out before the fun hit the fan.
She twisted a hank of hair around a finger. It was wet and had a silvery sheen. Not that she could be a day over 25. Maybe her hair silvered overnight after a fright. Some lousy john or hopped-up punk giving her the business. Well, she was lucky she’d landed in the hands of a professional. His work was elegant. It was art.
She leaned back in his chair. “You ever wonder if they’re dead under a load of farm dirt or alive and keeping a low profile until they figure out a way to get even?”
“The living got better things to do than hiking down Revenge Road and the dead don’t care where they’re at.”
“You ever think about the stuff before? The brutality.”
“Philosopher called Hobbes called it when he said life’s nasty, brutish and short.”
“Well, he’s a regular Mr. Congeniality.”
“He saw the truth and told it.”
He yanked Kim up and into his arms—she was a lightweight. He lowered his mouth to nuzzle her cleavage and let a hand slip along her inner thighs. She felt grainy, like damp sand. He was aroused, but she wriggled away.
Somehow, she was way out of reach and staring at him full-on with shadow-flecked eyes. Not the eyes of any Kim he remembered.
“I better go,” she said. “I’ll take the money owed.”
“Don’t owe you nothing,” he said, aware of the curl of his lips, his temper heating up. “You didn’t put out. You want cash, you better eat the pillow on that bed.”
“I didn’t hike across a cornfield for that, but I know enough to speak for Silver Star and a debt you never paid.”
Star Silver Kim happened thirty years back. Had she been this new Kim’s mom and the roofie set-up a ploy to even the score? Wow. That was interesting.
“Convince me about that debt,” he said, dropping into his chair. He stretched to grab her dragged her by her hips onto his lap. With one arm hooked around her waist to anchor her, he worked the cursor to bring up Silver Star’s face again. Her flatmate had contributed to the cop sketch and reported her missing but she hadn’t known her real name or that her body was six feet down about 200 feet east of the house. He’d never taken chances with photos or videos but he liked having the website’s portrait gallery at his fingertips.
“You mean this Kim?” he asked, stroking her image.
“What did you do to her?” she asked evenly.
“You look like the imaginative type. Guess.”
She struggled to pry herself off his lap, but he held her down even though she was squishy as a pillow or maybe slippery as if she’d smeared herself in liquid soap or melted lard. His heart muttered up a storm and he went all over clammy.
Performance nerves? He licked her ear. She tasted of clay. “You’re going nowhere, honey.”
“That so? You think you can hold onto me?”
“I know it.”
“Tell me how many you killed, Junior.”
“That’s not my name but that’s my score right there on the screen, barring maybe a couple in the early days.”
She quit struggling as if her predicament had upped and slapped her hard across the mouth. She overlapped the center hems of the robe. He didn’t like her wearing it. He’d have to burn it when he was through.
She reached to tap the space bar and the portrait array shivered as if to predict a power failure. It was par for the course where he was, but the re-visit had juiced him, and he imagined hurting lap Kim in all the same slow and careful ways as the others. Her skin rose in goosebumps as if someone stepped on her grave, and he relished the dread settling in the pit of her stomach, the fear feeding on her adrenaline.
Brief pressure on his inner thigh made him gasp with pleasure. Until his leg spasmed. He batted away Kim’s hand and the razorblade dropped to the floor. His white terry robe flooded with his own arterial blood. She’d hid the blade in the robe pocket, damn her.
“Call an ambulance now.” He shoved her off his lap and she floated from him like a balloon caught in the wind. The pain was a bitch out of hell, but why was he hallucinating? How long did he have? He tried to recall the stats.
Hovering a foot from the floor, Kim faced him and laughed. Only the first Kim had ever laughed at him. He’d been a kid then and a virgin on both counts.
He gritted, “Do. It. Now. Bitch.”
She leaned close, stinking of the grave, and tapped the flickering gallery of Kims who oozed from the screen like gobs of ghostly spittle. He managed to drag himself upright and limped away from them as the spittle solidified into his former playmates, Silver Star included, and some others he didn’t even know. He tripped over his shoelaces and fell heavily on his back as his office chair rolled away and the women closed in. Some were matronly, but he’d never interfered with a woman old enough to be his mother.
He sweated buckets, and his tongue clamped to the roof of his mouth. He wished he’d drunk that Dixie cup of water. Ten Dixie cups.
The dead women, most of them naked, some half-dressed in filthy rags, drew about him until their dangling hair and leering faces, and inside the faces vein and muscle and bone, blocked out the fly-speckled ceiling.
“Thing is,” new Kim said over his face. Her face translucent as an angel’s, but when he touched it with a fingertip, it burned like hot coal.
That voice. Was she sent from heaven to punish him?
“These gals and I,” she said, “formed a posse.
Why wouldn’t she call an ambulance? He reached weakly for her hand. “Save me. I’ll never hurt anyone again. I swear.”
“No chance, Junior. We’re hunting serials, or haunting to be precise. I used to be a regular Betty Crocker right here in this farmhouse until your dad choked me with a stocking for the last time.”
“No way. My whore mother ran off.”
“She was wheelbarrowed off, doubled up in a plywood box.”
He patched his wound with his hands and watched the blood seeping through his fingers. He was faint. He wanted to throw up. If she was his mother, she had to help him.
“I’d planned on leaving the bastard,” she said conversationally as if telling her story trumped his actual damn survival, “and I’d have taken you for sure. But out there so long, I forgot your name, Junior. Once I’d clawed myself out of the plywood and dirt, I sniffed you out, but it wasn’t until the others surfaced that I understood what I was dealing with. Just think, if the cops stumble across your remains—you know—from a wake of vultures sniffing you out—you’d become squatter John Doe on NamUs. Or maybe you’d be identified and hit the newspaper headlines as part of an infamous serial-killer duo: the Father and Son Cornfield Killers. Impressive, right?”
The cold killer eyes she had, full of shadows and spite.
“Don’t be sore. Consider yourself selected out of the dating game.” She bent down and extracted his wallet and keys from his pocket.
He made the effort to grab them but fell back with a whimper.
“We need funds for clothes and transport now we’re passing as human. Sorry about that, but we figure you owe a lot of us and your dad owes the rest.”
She squatted to tuck the blade between his fingers. “It’ll only hurt a little while. Isn’t that what you used to tell them? Now, ladies, give him a chance to do the decent thing.”
He breathed easier with a weapon in hand. “Call the cops. An ambulance. I won’t tell anyone how you cut me.”
She shrugged. “You planning to finish this like a man or what?”
Tears sprang from his eyes. “Mom. Please.”
“Looks like I bore his sniveling father’s son alright.”
The dead crowded him with the stink of rot and blood. They lay their bones and smell over him. They scratched and bit when he’d done the world a favor. Removed a few undesirables only, whores and bitches.
Perhaps he said it aloud, for Allentown Kim, who’d lasted for several pleasurable days, gripped that hunk of slate he’d set over her mutilated face and hammered it against his temple until the crack echoed through his every bone.
Mother Kim said, “It’s a hoot, right, the Name Us game counterpoint?”
From the corner of his functional eye, he saw her shake an admonishing finger at him. He watched her drag a box from under the bed and dress in clothes she’d taken from a bedroom closet—a calf-length skirt, a crisp shirt, and canvas sneakers. At this point, she looked like she’d stepped out of a magazine ad for laundry detergent or hair dye. It was the same outfit his mother wore in the photograph.
His own mother, who’d deserted him by dying, had set up the con and baited the honey-trap. She’d probably yanked the beach blanket out of the fire.
When she drew the drapes and sunlight flooded the room, he saw his blood, a tidal wave over the easy-clean linoleum flooring. His ears rang with screams. His own? The echo of theirs?
Mother Kim floated over his head. “He didn’t have much in him. I’d expected a show of strength. Who’ll do the coup-de-grace? I don’t want blood on my going-public clothes.”
Silver Star Kim took the blade from his slick fingers and squatted like a toad on his chest, from which position she meticulously gouged his last seeing eyeball from its socket.
“Done,” she said.